Page 109 - ARTE!Brasileiros #56
P. 109

the capital of Brazil is no longer Rio de Janeiro, it is   curator brought the event into a direct relationship   one of the first sets of the show, a display that shows
          transferred to Brasília and materializes an aesthetic   with the new, exposed the postal art, the video text,   a rock burned along with the entire building of the
          ideology launched by Le Corbusier. It was just the   showed the anti-art of the Fluxus group, opened it to   Museu Nacional in 2018, and that, because of the
          beginning of an explosive era. Mario Pedrosa, the   the performances of the English duo Gilbert & George   heat, went from amethyst, a variety of quartz of violet
          best known Brazilian critic internationally, is chosen   and provided a deep analysis of Arte Incomum with   color, to citrine, yellowish in color. “It’s still the same
          as curator of the edition, which exhibited a consistent   participation of psychoanalysts and scholars on the   rock because it knew how to transform,” explains the
          retrospective of the German Kurt Schwitters, a   production of people with mental illnesses.  text next to the window.
          revolutionary in the assemblages who influenced   In the process of occupying the 33,000 square   This vision of resistance, which is already after all
          the pop Robert Rauschenberg. Pedrosa exhibited   meters of the Bienal’s pavilion, the 18th edition,   in the terrible title of the Biennial - an excerpt from
          works by Maria Helena da Silva, who won the award,   curated by Sheila Leirner, distinguished itself with   Thiago de Mello’s poem, from 1965, when associating
          and also showed the socialist realism of the Italian   the impact caused by Grande Tela, a set of three   the black with something negative was not a poetic
          Renato Guttuso and the paintings of the Mexican   corridors measuring 100 meters each that displayed   license in question, as it is being attentive today - ends
          muralist Orozco. Pedrosa, since years before, wanted   hundreds of neo-expressionist paintings from various   up reinforcing, at the end, a vision of meritocracy:
          to show suprematism, the revolutionary movement   countries. Also in this edition, Marina Abramović and   “Because it knew how to transform itself”. And what
          created by Malevich in 1915 and consolidated in the   Ulay finished the performance Nightsea Crossing,   about all the other treasures, burned, that turned to
          first years of the Russian Revolution, but ended up   started at the Sydney Biennale in 1981 and which   dust because they weren’t rocks?
          bringing in insignificant young artists, which, in some   totaled almost 600 hours and 94 days. In it, the   Thus, what is perceived from the very beginning is
          ways, has let down certain critics and artists.  performative couple remained seated, looking at   that it is a show about a capacity of resistance based
                                            each other for seven hours, in seven days, without   more on individualistic than collective actions, on
          DiCtatorship anD repression       moving. Alex Vallauri takes his mundane graffiti to   isolated rather than community acts.
          The 1960s shook the world and the Bienal, also   the Bienal and builds the house of the “Queen of   Other examples in the same vein are the thought-
          affected by political-ideological changes, tries   Roasted Chicken”, personified by his friend, the   provoking portraits of Frederick Douglass (1818-1895),
          to survive under Pedrosa’s slogan: “Art is the   actress Claudia Raia, then 18 years old.  a black American abolitionist, and especially the
          experimental exercise of freedom”. It was the time   It would be unwise to neglect the 24th edition, from   “Black Admiral”, leader of the Chibata Revolt, João
          of counterculture, Vietnam war, Latin American   1998, with its approach charged with “brasilidade”,   Candido (1880-1969). Arrested in 1910, in the dungeon
          dictatorships. The 1964 civil-military coup, delivered   translated into Antropofagia and curated by Paulo   of Ilha das Cobras, in Rio de Janeiro, he participates
          against Brazilian democracy, put many intellectuals in   Herkenhoff. The cross-sectional historical exhibition   in the “Biennial of Hope” with two embroideries
          prison. The period coincides with the Bienal’s decline.   included works from the colonial period of the   made there, while 16 cellmates died asphyxiated.
          In 1965, Maria Bonomi, upon receiving the award for   19th century and established juxtapositions with   Released two years later, he was expelled from the
          best engraver, takes the trophy with one hand and,   contemporaneity, as in Tunga’s Eixo Exógeno, which   Navy and had a life of deprivation. Romanticizing
          with the other, hands over to President Castelo Branco   dialogued with the painting Lea e Maura, by Guignard,   these embroideries verges on being perverse.
          a letter signed by intellectuals and artists asking for   one of the girls portrayed being Tunga’s mother. The   At this time, it is unavoidable the question of what
          the release of critic Mário Schenberg, of sociologist   silent contemplation of the visitors contrasted with   led the team of curators, composed of Jacopo Crivelli
          Fernando Henrique Cardoso and other intellectuals.  the strident objects gathered in Paulo Bruscky’s   Visconti (general), Paulo Miyada (adjunct) and the
           Two years later, iconic works of American pop   room in the 26th edition, 2004, curated by Alfons   guests Carla Zaccagnini, Francesco Stocchi and Ruth
          art land at the Bienal. Works by Andy Warhol, Roy   Hug, whose reinterpretations opened up to other   Estévez to select examples of actions of resistance
          Lichtenstein, Jasper Johns, Robert Rauschenberg   experiences of time and memory.  in distant times, when one is facing the greatest
          and Robert Indiana show that one can work with the   At the 2006 Bienal, curated by Lisette Lagnado,   health crisis of the last 100 years, which has shaken
          icons of a country’s mass culture, with criticism and   American artist Jimmie Durham, of Aboriginal origin,   the artistic activity in a catastrophic way, combined
          humor, without making it socialist realism. The award   wrote an open letter that he sent along with his work,   with the unprecedented political crisis in Brazil, which
          is given to Jasper Johns for the series Three Flags,   in which he denounced the situation of indigenous   virtually made unfeasible the laws to culture support.
          while Quissak Júnior, a young Brazilian artist, had   people in Brazil, stating that the Bienal had not been   We live the politics of the culturally scorched-earth,
          his work banned by the police for using the national   interested in the subject. This intervention to confront   but the biennial sings.
          flag. Brazilian pop also showed its dimension with   colonialism was an unusual milestone. By choosing   There is virtually no reference to the present, and,
          works critical to the system, such as those by Claudio   Incerteza Viva as the theme, curator Jochen Volz   scheduled to be held last year, the exhibition now
          Tozzi, Antonio Henrique Amaral, Rubens Gerchman   placed the environment in the debate of the 32nd   on display ignores the urges of those who actually
          and Nelson Leirner. Quoting Michel Foucault, “power   Bienal de São Paulo, edition with major participation   resist. Perhaps it is in their own good will to want to
          produces before it represses; it produces ways of   of women and the first black co-curator, Gabi Ngcobo.  give some kind of hope that the show sinks into an
          living and it produces realities”*.  In recent years, the Bienal has opened its doors   escape from the present. The French writer André
           Two years later, the Bienal suffered an international   to various collectives of artists who gravitated, still   Gide (1869-1951) argued that “good literature is not
          boycott as a result of military intervention in the   oblivious, around Brazilian production. Most with   done with good intentions or good feelings”. The
          exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art in Rio,   gender insertion, Afro-descendant and indigenous   same stands for a biennial, of course.
          which exhibited the works that would go to the 6th   minorities, who updated the dialogue, but not always   There is more biennial atmosphere in the show
          Paris Bienal; some were considered offensive to   with works worthy of a biennial. There is no single   Dizer Não, organized by Ateliê 397, in its new space in
          the regime. Mario Pedrosa was exiled to Chile in   worldview as a means to relate the present to the past,   the neighborhood of Barra Funda, than in Ibirapuera
          1971 and provoked a letter of repudiation signed   memory to identity and to open up to the multiplicity   Park. There are hard-hitting works, such as João
          by dozens of personalities, such as Octavio Paz   of readings and debates about current socio-political   Loureiro’s installation, Serpente, which houses a
          and Pablo Picasso. Contrary to expectations,   demands. The Bienal de São Paulo reaches its 34th   boa constrictor hidden in the environment.
          leftist critic Mário Schenberg did not boycott the   edition and shows signs that the artistic and political
          Bienal. For him, staying was a form of resistance,   moment calls for deep reflection and new attitudes   inDigenous presenCe
          of guaranteeing the place of protest. Convinced of   to overcome the poverty and obscurity that currently   Although too sanitized, which also includes
          his position, he organizes a hall with young artists,   grips Brazil.  architecture, even if innovative in materials and
          among them José Roberto Aguilar, Carmela Gross,                     transparencies, Faz escuro mas eu canto has a
          Ione Saldanha, Claudio Tozzi and João Câmara. The   *Loose translation from Portuguese  historical presence of indigenous artists: Daiara
          Bienal was experiencing a sad moment when it saw                    Tukano, Sueli Maxakali, Jaider Esbell, Uyra and
          the biggest art project the country had ever had in   review 34   sÃo paulo BiEnnial [paGEs 18 and 19]  Gustavo Caboco. It is not, however, a research with
                                                  tH
          tatters. And why has Brazil never received the Grand                new discoveries, after all the group in its entirety has
          Prix (Itamaraty) at the Bienal de São Paulo? There   “BIENNIAL OF HOPE”   been already inserted in the contemporary art circuit,
          was never a convincing explanation. What is known                   having participated in exhibitions at Pinacoteca do
          is that the only Latin American country to achieve this   ROMANTICIZES   Estado (Véxoa-nós sabemos, organized by Naine
          feat was Argentina in 1977, with Grupo de los Trece,                Terena, in 2020), Museu de Arte Moderna do Rio de
          led by Jorge Glusberg.            CATASTROPHES                      Janeiro and even at Centro Cultural Banco do Brasil,
                                                                              with the exhibition Vaivém in 2019. Undoubtedly it is
          DemoCratization                   Faz escuro mas eu canto (Though It’s    a deservedly conquered presence, which someday
          In the 1980s, with the beginning of the political   Dark, Still I Sing), in Ibirapuera Park,    also needs to reach the curatorship, a difficult issue
          overture, the countries that signed the boycott   brings significant and aestheticising    in the institution, which continues with under-
          returned to the Bienal. Galleries multiply and the traffic   sets of Brazilian artists, but leaves   representation in the presence of women and without
          of the international artistic community intensifies,   transgressive activities in the past  any black representation in the general direction of
          no longer just centered on the event period, but                    the show; in what Venice and Kassel, with whom the
          throughout the whole year. Walter Zanini takes over   By faBio cypriano  Bienal de São Paulo likes to compare, are already
          the 1981 edition emphasizing the experimental and                   much more advanced.
          creates zones of questioning, without worrying about   Faz escuro mas eu canto, the 34th São Paulo   The 34th Biennial also brings significant sets
          certainties. Like Harald Szeemann, he is directly   Biennial is undoubtedly a “Biennial of Hope”, as   of star artists on the circuit, such as Antonio Dias
          involved with artists in carrying out their work. He   promised by the direction of the institution. Many   (1944-2018), Lygia Pape (1927-2004), Lasar Segall
          changes the structure of the Bienal, exchanging the   are the works that seek to point to a character of   (1889-1957) and Eleonore Koch (1926-2018). Groups
          montage by countries for the language analogy. The   resilience, transformation through struggle, as in   of artworks always pleasant to see, but that look
                                                                                                           109
   104   105   106   107   108   109   110   111   112   113   114